She Got a Two-Year Restraining Order Against Her Estranged Husband. Six Days Later She Was Found Dead at Home. Court Records Show a Judge Had Already Doubted a Letter Dropping Her First Abuse Case

TOWN OF BRADLEY, Wis. — A 50-year-old Wisconsin woman who had gone to court twice this fall seeking protection from her husband has been found dead in her home. He is in jail in connection with her death, and court records show warning signs going back to September.

What Happened

The victim is Belinda Davidson, 50. Bradley is the township that wraps around the city of Tomahawk in Lincoln County.

  • The call: The clock read about 10:35 a.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 17, when someone asked dispatchers to check on her. She had not shown up for work and was not answering her phone.
  • The discovery: deputies decided they needed to go inside her home, and they found her dead.
  • The finding: the sheriff’s office has not released a cause of death, but said, “It did not appear her death was natural or accidental.”

The Arrest

Her estranged husband, Jason McDonald, 45, is being held in the Lincoln County Jail.

The arrest came at about 6:28 a.m. the next day, during a search by the county’s Special Response Team at a home on West Jackson Street in Merrill.

State investigators from the Wisconsin Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation are assisting county detectives.

The sheriff’s office says McDonald was arrested in connection with her death. The exact charge has not been made public. Lincoln County Circuit Court is where he is due on Monday for a first appearance.

The Court Record This Fall

Online court records, first reported by Law&Crime, show how often Davidson had turned to the courts in the weeks before she died.

DateWhat happened
Sept. 23Davidson files for a restraining order, citing domestic abuse and harassment
Oct. 7The case is dismissed after neither spouse appears at the hearing
Nov. 2She files for a second restraining order on the same grounds
Nov. 9She files for divorce
Nov. 11A judge grants her request to keep the order in place for two years
Nov. 17She is found dead

The Letter the Court Did Not Trust

The October dismissal stands out. A letter asking for the case to be dropped had been filed, but the court noted that it did not believe the letter was in Davidson’s own handwriting.

The court then asked law enforcement to carry out a welfare check on her. The records do not show what came of that check.

The Second Order

Less than a month later Davidson was back in court. This time the order was granted.

At the Nov. 11 hearing she asked for it to stay in force for two years, and the judge agreed. McDonald was still allowed contact with their son.

She did not go to that hearing alone. HAVEN, a Merrill agency for victims of domestic violence and sexual assault, sent someone with her.

Six days separated that two-year injunction from the discovery of her body, the Wausau Pilot & Review noted.

The couple also had a hearing scheduled for December.

Where the Case Stands

The investigation is continuing. McDonald has been arrested but not convicted of anything, and he is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top