
EAU CLAIRE, Wis. — The US Department of Education is investigating whether the Eau Claire Area School District’s gender support guidelines for students break federal privacy laws. The district is one of five across the country named in the inquiry this week.
What Is Being Investigated
The investigation is being run by the department’s Student Privacy Policy Office, or SPPO.
Two federal laws are at the center of it: the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, known as FERPA, and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment, or PPRA. Taken together, those laws give parents access to their children’s education records and require parental consent before schools collect certain private information from students.
The department’s press release focuses on Eau Claire’s “Gender Support Plan” form. According to the department, the form asks a student for:
- A preferred name, gender identity and pronouns
- How safe they feel with their parents knowing about their gender transition and identity
- Who they trust at school
- Which bathrooms and locker rooms they feel they belong in
What the Department Says
SPPO Director Frank Miller said it is unacceptable for schools to withhold highly sensitive information about students from their own parents.
He said the law, not the school, decides what information is shared with parents, and that his office will hold institutions accountable for upholding parental rights.
The department says the district’s federal funding could be at risk.
What the District Says
The district said it received the department’s letter and is reviewing it. In a written statement, it said it takes its legal obligations seriously, is committed to complying with federal and state law, and will respond through the appropriate process.
School Board President Stephanie Farrar went further in an interview with WEAU 13 News. She called the investigation “a tired attempt to create controversy and conflict in our community.”
- Nothing is hidden from parents and the district follows state and federal law, according to Farrar’s comments to WEAU.
- The district’s federal money mainly supports services for students with disabilities and school nutrition, she said.
- Parents’ right to request their student’s records is written into the plan itself, a local TV report noted.
The district’s gender support plan dates to 2017.
The Other Four Districts
The other four are Colonial School District in Pennsylvania, Thompson School District in Colorado, Community Unit School District 300 in Illinois and St. Paul Public Schools in Minnesota.
Their early responses have been brief. District 300 in Illinois has said it will cooperate fully, and Thompson says it is evaluating the notice.
Earlier Court Challenges Failed
This is not the first challenge to Eau Claire’s guidelines, but it is the first from the federal government.
| Year | What happened |
|---|---|
| 2022 | A group of parents, represented by the conservative Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty, sued, arguing the policy violated parents’ constitutional rights |
| 2023 | A federal judge dismissed the case, finding the parents lacked standing because their claims rested on a chain of speculative future events |
| 2024 | The 7th US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal, noting that no individual parent had alleged an actual or imminent injury |
Those rulings were about who had the right to sue. They did not decide whether the policy itself is lawful.
The new investigation is different in kind. It is an administrative inquiry under privacy statutes, not a constitutional lawsuit, and the federal government does not have to show standing in the same way private parents did.
A Similar Fight in Kansas
The US Department of Justice has sued a Kansas public school system, citing the same privacy laws. That case is ongoing. The school system has asked for it to be dismissed, arguing that the government’s claims rest on hypotheticals and that no legal injury has occurred.
What Happens Next
- The district will respond to the department’s letter.
- The Student Privacy Policy Office will review the district’s forms and record-keeping.
- If it finds a violation, the department can seek changes, and federal funding can ultimately be withheld if a district does not comply.
No findings have been made. An investigation is not a conclusion that the district broke the law

Walter M. Hartman is a writer at smhsbreeze.com, where he covers weather, school news, college news, and other stories. He focuses on clear, accurate, and timely reporting that keeps students, families, and readers informed about what matters in their community.