Bar Fight Turns Bloody in Downtown Arroyo Grande: Customer Stabbed and Slashed Multiple Times at Bill’s Place, and Police Find the Suspect Sitting in a Car Outside With a Woman Beside Him

ARROYO GRANDE, Calif. — A night out at a downtown bar ended with one man in the hospital with multiple stab wounds and another in handcuffs. Arroyo Grande police arrested a 34-year-old Grover Beach man on Thursday evening after a fight between two customers at Bill’s Place.

The Arrest

Police identified the suspect as John Arnold Martinez Jr., 34, of Grover Beach. He was arrested on suspicion of two offenses:

  • Assault with a deadly weapon
  • Battery causing serious bodily injury

The assault count specifies a deadly weapon other than a firearm. Reports so far do not say what the weapon was.

How It Unfolded

The call came in at about 6:56 p.m. on Nov. 19 and sent officers to Bill’s Place at 112 East Branch Street.

The situation got worse while the caller was still on the line:

  • First report: Two complaints were made at the start, that a man was being disruptive inside the bar and that he had been driving erratically in the parking lot.
  • Then: the caller told police the same man had gotten into a physical fight with another customer.
  • When officers arrived: they found Martinez in the driver’s seat of a car, with a woman in the passenger seat.

Both were detained without a struggle. Police have reported an arrest only for Martinez.

The Victim

Investigators then learned how serious the fight had been. The other customer had been stabbed and cut multiple times.

He was treated at the scene and taken to a hospital, where he was reported to be in stable condition. Police have not released his name.

Where It Happened

Bill’s Place sits in the Village of Arroyo Grande. East Branch Street is the main street through that part of town and is lined with shops and restaurants. The stabbing happened in the early evening, when the area is usually busy.

Still Under Investigation

Police have not said what started the fight or whether the two men knew each other. The investigation is continuing.

Detective Brandon Earnest is taking tips at 805-473-5127.

Martinez has been arrested on suspicion of these offenses and has not been convicted. He is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top