
BOSTON — Lindsay Clancy’s lawyers have won a hearing before the highest court in Massachusetts. The Supreme Judicial Court agreed on Thursday to take up her argument that a second murder trial would be unconstitutional, and it will hear the case in January, two months before that retrial is due to start.
What the Court Agreed To
Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar issued the order on Nov. 19. In it she noted that the court uses this kind of supervisory power only in “the most exceptional circumstances” and only when no other adequate remedy exists.
The schedule is tight:
- Dec. 3: Clancy’s brief is due.
- Dec. 17: Prosecutors must respond.
- January 2027: Oral argument before the court.
- Feb. 18: Final pretrial hearing in the trial court.
- March 29: Retrial set to begin.
Her attorneys filed the petition on Monday, and prosecutors opposed it.
The Case Behind the Appeal
Clancy is charged with murder in the deaths of her three children, 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, in January 2023.
At trial she did not contest that she strangled them with exercise bands on Jan. 24, 2023. The question for the jury was her mental state. Jurors could not agree on whether she was criminally responsible for the killings.
The first trial ended on Sept. 4 with the jury split 11-1. The majority apparently favored finding her not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, and one juror held out. The panel had deliberated for seven days before reporting it was deadlocked.
What the Defense Is Arguing
Attorneys Kevin Reddington and Martin Weinberg say a second trial would put Clancy in double jeopardy, which the Constitution forbids.
Their argument centers on that one juror. During deliberations, the foreperson sent the judge a note claiming the holdout was not following the jury instructions. The defense says the juror acknowledged reasonable doubt but refused to apply the law, and that the judge should have questioned him before ending the trial.
The petition contends that the judge had workable options short of a mistrial, even though he believed otherwise at the time.
Why the Trial Judge Said No
Judge William Sullivan rejected that argument in a 17-page order on Nov. 9. His main points:
- The foreperson’s note did not reasonably show that the juror was unable to deliberate or follow the law.
- With only one holdout, singling that juror out for questioning would have been improperly coercive.
- The deadlock made a mistrial necessary, so a retrial does not violate double jeopardy protections.
In the same round of rulings, Sullivan turned down a defense request to investigate the holdout juror and a prosecution request for a gag order. That juror has since said publicly that he had no doubts.
How Big a Win Is This
Getting a hearing does not mean winning the appeal. Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge who has followed the case, told Fox News it was “a small win for the defense.”
The outcomes are far apart. If the court sides with Clancy, the murder charges could be dismissed. If it sides with prosecutors, the March retrial goes ahead as planned.
There is a recent precedent in the same court. In the Karen Read case, the justices heard a double jeopardy challenge after a hung jury and ruled against the defendant, and she was tried again.
Where Clancy Is Now
Clancy remains in custody at Tewksbury Hospital while the case continues.
Joel J. Wallace is a writer and editor at smhsbreeze.com, where he covers local news and crime stories. He focuses on clear, accurate, and timely reporting that keeps readers informed about the events and issues shaping their community today.