
CITRUS HEIGHTS, Calif. — For four years, nobody reported Paul Fitzmaurice missing. Investigators now say that was deliberate. His wife and daughter are in jail, accused of killing him, scattering his remains through the Placer County forest and telling relatives he was still alive.
The Arrests
Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, and her mother, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, were arrested on Tuesday, Nov. 17, after Placer County sheriff’s detectives searched the family’s home in Citrus Heights.
The victim is Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73, a retired California state worker. Detectives concluded that Mary killed him inside the family home and that the two women then worked together to get rid of his body.
Both are being held without bail at the South Placer Jail.
A Head in a Trash Bag
The case began on Sept. 28, 2022, when a woman walking her dog found a severed human head inside a garbage bag in Foresthill. It turned up in the Todd Valley area, at a time when the Mosquito Fire was burning nearby.
Identifying it was hard:
- Decomposition: Because of the condition of the remains, investigators could not tell who the man was.
- First steps: Forensic specialists at CSU Chico worked up an age and race profile and an artist’s sketch, and a CODIS search of his DNA produced no match.
- The break: In January 2024, testing at the private lab Othram pointed to possible distant relatives.
- The match: FBI agents helped interview those relatives and collect DNA samples, which led to the name Paul Fitzmaurice.
That is when detectives learned he had last been living with his wife and daughter, and that neither had ever reported him gone.
What the Court Filing Alleges
A criminal complaint filed on Thursday in Placer County Superior Court gives the first detailed account from prosecutors:
- When: Paul was killed sometime between Sept. 16 and Sept. 28, 2022.
- How: Prosecutors say Mary used a deadly weapon but have not named it. District Attorney Morgan Gire said injuries to the head may indicate how Paul died.
- The disposal: The body was allegedly divided among six garbage bags at the home and loaded into Mary’s vehicle.
- The drive: The women allegedly headed toward Foresthill and stopped at several spots in the forest, carrying the torso into the trees and leaving the head at a separate location.
Only the head has ever been recovered. Prosecutors believe the rest was scattered in different places.
Four Years of Cover Stories
Sheriff Wayne Woo said the two women “kept up the facade” with family and friends that Paul was alive.
Paul had not been in touch with many relatives in the years before his death, Woo said. The women reportedly explained his absence by saying he had become a recluse, would vanish for days and was struggling with substance abuse.
The story continued until days before the arrests, according to the complaint. Mary allegedly repeated it on Nov. 11 in Roseville to an investigator posing as a Citrus Heights police officer, and both women allegedly said the same to sheriff’s deputies on Nov. 17.
Money kept coming in the whole time. Gwenn is accused of collecting her husband’s CalPERS pension and Social Security payments through November 2026 without ever reporting his death.
The Charges
| Defendant | Charges |
|---|---|
| Mary Fitzmaurice, 45 (daughter) | Murder, with a weapon-use enhancement; conspiracy to obstruct justice |
| Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75 (wife) | Accessory after the fact; two counts of felony grand theft tied to the pension and Social Security payments; conspiracy to obstruct justice |
Gire said the conspiracy charge covers the lies the women allegedly told about Paul being alive.
In Court
The two appeared in court on Thursday and were given appointed defense attorneys. Gwenn was brought in using a wheelchair.
Neither woman entered a plea. Their next hearing is Dec. 4, and Gire said bail and custody may be argued then.
Authorities have not offered a motive. Gire called the case disturbing but said the burden of proof is the same as in any other criminal case. Both women are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Joel J. Wallace is a writer and editor at smhsbreeze.com, where he covers local news and crime stories. He focuses on clear, accurate, and timely reporting that keeps readers informed about the events and issues shaping their community today.