
CASPER, Wyo. — A Casper woman who claimed she stabbed her husband in self-defense has been found guilty, after jurors saw home security footage of her striking herself with a sledgehammer hours before the attack. She told investigators the hammer blows were a treatment for fibromyalgia.
The Verdict
A Natrona County jury convicted Tabatha Richardson on Wednesday of aggravated assault and battery, Oil City News reported.
- The jury: Ten men and two women sat on the panel, and they needed less than two hours.
- Custody: She is now held without bond until sentencing. Before trial she had been out on a $30,000 bond.
- Possible sentence: up to 10 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
No sentencing date had been set as of Friday afternoon.
What Happened on Dec. 9, 2025
Both spouses called 911 that day, and each gave a different account.
His account. The husband said he was on the couch feeding their infant son. The baby was four months old at the time. He said Richardson said something to him “out of nowhere,” and then he felt something hit the right side of his neck. When he saw blood on his hand, he ran from the house and called for help. He told investigators the attack was unprovoked and that he feared for his children.
Her account. Richardson told the dispatcher that she had simply walked past him and he attacked her. She later said he punched her in the ribs while she was holding the baby, and that she pulled a folding knife from her bra and stabbed him to get him off her.
Why Investigators Did Not Believe Her
Detectives found several problems with the self-defense story:
- No struggle: the home had blood in it but no signs of a fight.
- The knife: it had no spring-assist mechanism, so it was unlikely to be opened with one hand. Richardson tried to show how she did it and failed. Investigators could not open and lock it one-handed either.
- Her phone: she had sent herself messages about domestic abuse, along with material about testifying on abuse.
- Her medical records: they showed no documented history of abuse by her husband. They did show she was worried about divorce and losing custody.
- His phone: a review found nothing suggesting he had been abusive.
The Sledgehammer Video
The key evidence came from a camera in the bedroom.
About two to three hours before the stabbing, the footage showed Richardson hitting herself several times with a small sledgehammer. Part of what the camera caught was her shadow swinging the hammer. The affidavit said the blows looked just hard enough to leave marks.
Investigators later saw bruises on her that were round and matched the shape of the hammer head.
The fibromyalgia explanation first surfaced when sheriff’s investigator Cory Brooks showed her the footage. She said she had been trying an alternative treatment for the chronic pain condition. Jurors did not accept it.
At Trial
Deputy District Attorney Blaine Nelson built the state’s case around planning, telling jurors the attack was thought out in advance. Richardson’s public defenders said she would tell her own story of defending herself.
The husband testified. He described feeling a dull, blunt pain in his neck, like a punch, and said that when he shouted at her, she answered that he had beaten her.
In closing, prosecutors returned to the video of the hammer blows.
How Long It Took
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Dec. 9, 2025 | The stabbing at the couple’s Casper home |
| March 2026 | Richardson is charged after about three months of investigation |
| May 2026 | She pleads not guilty |
| Nov. 16, 2026 | Trial opens |
| Nov. 18, 2026 | Guilty verdict |
Joel J. Wallace is a writer and editor at smhsbreeze.com, where he covers local news and crime stories. He focuses on clear, accurate, and timely reporting that keeps readers informed about the events and issues shaping their community today.